You've probably seen the incredible photographs the Brazilian government recently released of an uncontacted tribe deep in the heart of the Amazon. The photographs --
you can see several of them here at MSNBC -- show naked men of the tribe bravely brandishing their bows and arrows at the aircraft occupants who took the pictures.
A connection exists between this story and the scientific search for extraterrestrial intelligence, as I'll explain in a minute.
Anthropologists know virtually nothing about the Brazilian tribe, and there may be as many as 70 other uncontacted tribes in the Amazon -- although only 24 have been confirmed. The Brazilian government has
known about the uncontacted tribe's existence for 20 years, but released the photographs now out of fear the encroachment of illegal loggers and settlers will endanger the tribe's survival.
Uncontacted tribes tend to
react with hostility when they encounter anyone from the modern world, and with good reason. Contact has proven to be deadly for them, as they do not have a natural resistance to many modern diseases, such as chicken pox or even the common cold. First contact tends to result in a
mortality rate for isolated tribes as high as 50% within months. The Brazilian government has adopted a policy of protecting the tribes from the outside world rather than encouraging contact.
The Brazilian government's no-contact policy and
this quote by a government official in the Brazilian Indian Affairs office caught my eye: contact and the dire effects it has had on uncontacted tribes are "a monumental crime against the natural world" and "further testimony to the complete irrationality with which we, the 'civilised' ones, treat the world".
I've
posted several times about various solutions to the
Fermi Paradox, but this story raises what may be one of the more credible explanations for why we have yet to hear from or be contacted by an advanced extraterrestrial civilization: the
Zoo Hypothesis. (I say credible because you can base the hypothesis, in part, on our own ethical development. It has taken us 500 years, but the Brazilian situation shows we have progressed ethically in how we treat indigenous peoples, at least compared to
the Conquistadors.)
Well known to fans of the original
Star Trek series as the
Prime Directive, the principle behind the
Zoo Hypothesis is based on a similar ethical precept embraced by the Brazilian government in regard to uncontacted tribes: an advanced civilization should not contact a less advanced civilization if doing so would harm the less advanced civilization.
We know that if other intelligent species share the galaxy with us, statistically they are likely
to be vastly older and more advanced than we are. If we are not alone, we are almost certainly the babies in the family. And our galactic neighbors, if they exist, are likely to be far more advanced compared to Westernized humans than Westernized humans are compared to uncontacted tribes like those in Brazil.
It is reasonable to suppose that an
extraterrestrial advanced technological civilization is also an advanced ethical civilization. Even humans try -- at least in some cases such as the Brazilian one -- to treat less technologically advanced societies in an ethical manner.
If an advanced extraterrestrial civilization is out there, listening to us or even watching us, we should hope they view Earth as a big zoo -- where we are the exhibit and just have no clue we are being observed.